In-House vs Outsourced IT: Which Is Right for Your Business? (2026 Guide)

A plain comparison for Australian businesses of 15 to 70 staff: what each model gives you, the benefits and downsides of IT outsourcing, what an IT hire really costs, and when to combine the two.

BlogPublished 14 November 2026Last edited 14 November 2026Sydney, Australia

The short answer

In-house IT means employing your own IT staff. Outsourced IT means paying a provider to run some or all of your technology, usually as managed IT services.

  • Outsource if you have no IT staff, or one person stretched across support, security and projects.
  • Keep IT in-house if technology is your product, or you need someone on site every day for specialised systems.
  • Combine the two (co-managed IT) if you have an internal IT person who needs depth, security cover and a backup.

For most businesses of 15 to 70 staff, outsourcing gives broader skills, cover during leave and 24/7 security monitoring one hire cannot provide alone.

Key statistics

FigureWhat it measuresSource
$68,000Median base salary for an IT support specialist in Sydney, before super, leave cover, training and tools. The middle 80% earn $54,000 to $92,000Payscale, IT Support Specialist salary in Sydney
12%Superannuation guarantee employers pay on top of salary, from 1 July 2025Australian Taxation Office
$56,600Average self-reported cost of a cybercrime report for an Australian small business in 2024-25, up 14%ASD Annual Cyber Threat Report 2024-25
30%Share of breaches involving a third party such as a supplier or service provider, up from 15% the year beforeVerizon 2025 Data Breach Investigations Report

What is the difference between in-house and outsourced IT?

In-house IT is staff you employ. Outsourced IT is a provider you contract. The real difference is how many skills you get and who covers the gaps.

In-house ITOutsourced IT (managed services)
Who does the workOne or more employeesA team at the provider
SkillsWhatever your hire knowsHelp desk, Microsoft 365, networks and security across the team
Leave, sickness and resignationsGaps unless you hire a second personCovered by the rest of the team
Security monitoringBusiness hours, at bestUsually 24/7, with tools included
Knowledge of your businessDeep, from being there every dayBuilds over time with a consistent team
Cost patternSalary, super, training and toolsA monthly fee per user or device
Best forLarge teams or IT-heavy businessesBusinesses of roughly 15 to 70 staff

In-house IT vs managed services is rarely all or nothing. Many businesses keep one internal person and outsource the rest.

What is IT outsourcing?

IT outsourcing is paying an outside provider to run some or all of your technology instead of employing people to do it.

Common information technology outsourcing examples:

  • A help desk answering staff calls and tickets
  • Device setup, patching and monitoring
  • Microsoft 365 administration, accounts and licences
  • Security monitoring, endpoint protection and email filtering
  • Backups and disaster recovery
  • Network, Wi-Fi and internet management
  • Projects such as office moves or cloud migrations

IT business process outsourcing is a different thing. It hands over a business function, such as payroll or accounts processing, instead of the technology behind it.

What is the difference between managed services and outsourcing?

Managed services are one type of outsourcing. The provider is paid to keep your IT working, not for hours or a person, so preventing problems is part of the job.

ModelWhat you buyWho carries the risk
Staff augmentationAn engineer’s time, often on siteYou: you direct the work
Break-fixA fix each time something failsYou: nobody is paid to prevent problems
Project outsourcingA defined project with an end dateShared, for that project only
Managed servicesOngoing responsibility for an agreed scopeThe provider, measured against service levels
Co-managed ITManaged services alongside your internal ITShared, with a clear split of duties

So when people compare managed service vs outsourcing, they are usually comparing managed services with staff augmentation or break-fix. See what outsourced IT support covers as a managed service.

Five reasons to outsource your IT

1You get a team instead of one person

One IT hire cannot be an expert in the help desk, Microsoft 365, networks and cyber security at once. A provider spreads that work across people who each know their area.

This is the biggest of the benefits of IT outsourcing for a business of 15 to 70 staff. It also means nobody inside the business has to be the "IT person" on top of their real job. Skills are the usual sticking point: when the ABS asked Australian businesses what held back their use of technology in 2024-25, insufficient staff skills was the most common answer, at 16% (ABS).

2Leave and resignations stop being a risk

When your only IT person is sick, on holiday or resigns, the knowledge often walks out with them.

A full-time employee is entitled to four weeks of annual leave and 10 days of personal leave a year under the National Employment Standards (Fair Work Ombudsman), so a one-person IT department can be away for up to six weeks a year before anyone resigns. An outsourced team documents your setup and covers absences.

  • Passwords and admin access are held in documented, shared systems
  • Another engineer picks up the ticket when someone is away
  • A resignation doesn’t leave you with nobody who knows your network

3Security is watched around the clock

Attackers don’t keep office hours. A managed provider monitors your systems 24/7, which is hard to staff in-house.

  • The average self-reported cost of a cybercrime report for an Australian small business was $56,600 in 2024-25, up 14% (ASD).
  • Medium businesses reported an average of $97,200, up 55% (ASD).
  • ASD responded to more than 1,200 cyber security incidents in 2024-25, up 11% on the year before (ASD).
  • Security tools such as endpoint detection, email filtering and backup software are usually included in the provider’s fee, instead of licensed separately.

4Costs become predictable

Outsourced IT is usually a monthly fee per user or device. An in-house hire brings salary, super, leave cover, recruitment, training and tools, and the costs rise each time someone leaves.

Predictable does not always mean cheaper, so compare the full cost of each option, not just a salary against a monthly fee. The section on the real cost of in-house IT below lists what to include.

5Your people get back to their real jobs

In many smaller businesses, IT falls to an office manager or a director by default. Outsourcing hands that work to people who do it every day.

The advantages of IT outsourcing show up as time: staff stop waiting for fixes, and the person who used to "do the IT" goes back to the work you hired them for.

What are the disadvantages of outsourcing IT?

The main risks are a provider who doesn’t know your business, slow on-site response and the security risk of giving a third party admin access. You can check all three before you sign.

RiskHow to reduce it
The provider does not learn your businessAsk for a consistent, named team instead of a general queue
Slow on-site visitsChoose a provider in your city, and ask how on-site work is handled
Third-party security riskA third party was involved in 30% of breaches in the Verizon 2025 DBIR. Ask the ACSC questions for managed service providers
Lock-inKeep admin accounts, domains and licences in your business name, and read the exit terms
Unclear scopeGet a written list of what is included and what is billed as extra

When does in-house IT make more sense?

Keep IT in-house when technology is central to what you sell, or when there is enough daily on-site work to keep a person busy.

  • Your product or service is software or technology
  • You have well over 70 staff, or several sites with daily hands-on needs
  • You run specialised systems needing someone on site every day
  • You already have an IT team and need extra depth, not a replacement (that is co-managed IT)

What does in-house IT really cost?

More than the salary. The median base salary for an IT support specialist in Sydney is about $68,000 (Payscale), and the employer adds 12% super on top (ATO). In NSW, a business whose total wages are above $1.2 million also pays payroll tax of 5.45% on wages above that threshold, and super counts as wages (Revenue NSW).

A worked example for one mid-range hire in Sydney:

CostAmount
Base salary (Payscale median)$68,000
Superannuation guarantee at 12%$8,160
NSW payroll tax at 5.45%, if your wages are already over the threshold$4,151
Subtotal before recruitment, training, tools and workers compensationAbout $80,300

When you compare in-house IT against outsourcing, include:

  • Salary, the 12% superannuation guarantee and any payroll tax
  • Workers compensation insurance, which NSW employers generally must hold
  • Leave cover, or the cost of going without IT during up to six weeks of leave a year
  • Recruitment, and rehiring when someone leaves
  • Training and certifications to keep skills current
  • Tools: monitoring, security, backup and documentation software
  • Management time spent directing and reviewing the work

A senior engineer or a security specialist costs more than an IT support specialist, and one person rarely covers both. Even within the same job title, Payscale’s range for Sydney runs from $54,000 to $92,000.

What is co-managed IT?

Co-managed IT is a shared model: your internal IT person keeps day-to-day ownership, and a managed provider adds depth, security monitoring, backups, projects and cover.

It suits businesses that have outgrown one IT person but value having someone inside who knows the business. It is also the gentlest way to start outsourcing.

How do you decide between in-house and outsourced IT?

Map the work and the gaps, cost a hire properly, get an assessment, then compare providers on the same questions.

  1. List the IT work happening today and who does it, including the jobs a manager or office administrator picks up on the side.
  2. Find the gaps, such as security monitoring, tested backups, documentation and cover when your IT person is away.
  3. Work out the full cost of a hire, including super, payroll tax, leave cover, recruitment, training and the tools an IT person needs.
  4. Get an outside assessment so you know what needs fixing before you decide who should fix it.
  5. Compare providers on the same questions using a checklist, so the answers line up.
  6. Pick the model that fits: fully outsourced, co-managed alongside your own IT person, or a single function such as the help desk.

Our guide on how to choose an MSP in Sydney has a 12-question checklist for the comparison step.

How does Elscomm handle outsourced IT?

We look after Sydney businesses of 15 to 70 staff, fully outsourced or alongside an internal IT person. One consistent team learns your setup, and the person who raised each ticket scores it.

  • Since 2006: supporting Sydney businesses from North Sydney.
  • 5.0 from 89 Google reviews: every review public and verifiable.
  • Live satisfaction score: the person who raised each support ticket scores it, and we publish the result on our reviews page.
  • Help desk: Monday to Friday, 8am to 5pm, with security monitored 24/7.
  • 90-day promise: three measurable improvements in your first 90 days, or we keep working free until you see them.

Frequently asked questions

Should we outsource our IT?

If you have no internal IT staff, or one person stretched across everything, it usually makes sense to outsource. You get a team with broader skills, security monitoring and cover during leave. Businesses with strong internal IT often outsource part of it instead, through co-managed IT.

Is managed IT better than in-house IT?

For most businesses of 15 to 70 staff, managed IT gives broader skills and better cover than one internal hire. Larger organisations often combine both: an internal person who knows the business, backed by a managed service provider.

What are the benefits of outsourced IT?

A team with broader skills, cover during leave and resignations, 24/7 security monitoring, more predictable costs, and staff who no longer do IT on the side.

What are the disadvantages of outsourcing IT?

A provider may not know your business as well as an employee, on-site visits can be slower, and a third party holds admin access. Choose a local provider with a named team, keep admin accounts in your business name, and check the exit terms.

How much does an in-house IT person cost in Sydney?

The median base salary for an IT support specialist in Sydney is about $68,000, according to Payscale. Employers add 12% super, plus leave cover, recruitment, training and tools.

Can you outsource only part of your IT?

Yes. Common options are the help desk only, security monitoring only, projects, or co-managed IT where a provider works alongside your internal IT person.

Will we lose control if we outsource IT?

Not if the arrangement is set up properly. Keep admin accounts, domains and licences in your business name, get a written scope, and ask for regular reviews of risk, spend and projects.

What happens to our internal IT person if we outsource?

Often they stay. Co-managed IT lets your internal person focus on the business and its systems while the provider covers the help desk, security monitoring and leave.

How long does it take to move to outsourced IT?

It depends on your current contracts and how well your setup is documented. A good provider secures admin access and documentation first, then cuts over support on an agreed date, with no downtime.

What is the difference between IT outsourcing and IT business process outsourcing?

IT outsourcing hands over your technology: support, devices, security and networks. IT business process outsourcing hands over a business function, such as payroll or accounts processing.

Sources

Published 14 November 2026. Last edited 14 November 2026.